A letter from Paul Grenville


Dear Nahida

I just read your piece, "You want a solution" so I have got one Palestinian perspective. I am English, born in 1956. I have never been to Palestine. But I know enough history to know that it was my nation who marched into Palestine in 1917 and gave a huge boost to the Zionist colonization which eventually made you homeless and stateless. This is my piece, below. It is on the site. I agree with your piece. It is better than mine. Ethically speaking, the Israeli state is a simple case of theft, murder and genocide. But it has only been partially "successful", unlike the American state, also founded as a result of the theft of land and the genocide of many indigenous peoples. So there is hope.

Just some questions. How can the "Zionist occupiers" give back the land and rebuild all the 500 destroyed villages and still live there? They will never never do this. I do not think the Zionists want a solution, as in peace. I think they can live with war, with torture, with genocide, and with the wall. I think they have to leave. They will only leave when things become too uncomfortable for them politically. This can only happen when the America stops financing its little colony. The defeat of Zionism will lead to an exodus of Zionists from the country. Jews who remain will not be Zionists. Palestinians will start to come home. There will be justice.

Then another question: who are the occupiers? 90% of the Jews who went to Palestine before 1948 were Europeans. They form most of the Zionist establishment today. After 1948 they recruited all the Arab Jews, Ethiopian Jews, Russian Jews, and so on. These are all profiting from the theft of Palestinian land and resources but mostly they are not the ruling class, the political Zionist elite. Today Jews can live anywhere in the world, free of persecution. There was never any need for a Jewish state: even today only 40% of the world’s Jews live there. The Nazi genocide of the Jews was a moment of history, a consequence of fascism. Did the European gypsys, also murdered by the Nazis in their concentration camps, get a state of their own?

I have just finished reading Hakim Kaneenah’s book "A doctor in the Galilee: the life and struggle of a Palestinian in Israel". I highly recommend it. He shows just what is possible for the Palestinians living right in the heart of the occupation state, in the Galilee. He also shows all the methods by which the Israeli state keeps the Palestinians in subjection, and how much collaboration is going on.

I shall keep my promise never to visit Israel. Being a tourist in a country signifies that you agree with what goes on there, and especially in the case of Israel, with its sickening worldwide media campaign, and a worldwide movement on its side,

with best wishes,  Paul Grenville                            

===                      


DSC00859 

I shall visit Israel

 

I shall visit Israel when the olive trees are in bloom

 

I shall visit Israel when Arabs can marry Jews

 

I shall visit Israel when the fabrication of history has stopped

 

I shall visit Israel when Torah Jews are no longer beaten up in the streets of Jerusalem for reminding their fellows of the commands of Moses –

 

Thou shalt not steal, thou shalt not kill, thou shalt not bear false witness

 

I shall visit Israel when the speaking of Arabic in certain neighbourhoods no longer causes heads to turn

 

I shall visit Israel when the learning of Arabic is mandatory in school

 

I shall visit Israel when Arab and Jewish children all go to the same schools

 

But will it still be Israel?

 

I shall visit Israel when the 7 million refugees’ descendants have a country they can call their own

 

I shall visit Israel when the invaders have left or those who remain have made peace with the invaded (not the other way about)

 

I shall visit Israel when West Bank settlers have gone and no longer shoot to kill the natives as a patriotic duty

 

I shall visit Israel when the shooting of children has stopped

 

I shall visit Israel when the spirit of Fanon has moved the peoples to withdraw this dagger from the Arab breast

 

I shall visit Israel when the people of the Pale have fled to Europe as their colony collapses

 

I shall visit Israel when the hands of Generals and Rabbis are no longer choking the throat of Palestine

 

I shall visit Israel when the Wall has been torn down and all the other walls have gone

 

I shall visit Israel when the house demolitions have ceased

 

I shall visit Israel when to be born Palestinian is not a reason to be humiliated and spurned, hunted and spied upon

 

But will it still be Israel?

 

I shall visit Israel when Jews have stopped arriving from far away and calling it their land

 

I shall visit Israel when the expulsions of Palestinians have stopped

 

I shall visit Israel when Gaza is no longer the cruel laboratory experiment in slow genocide that it is today

 

I shall visit Israel when her planes have stopped bombing and strafing towns in Gaza and terrifying the people at night with sonic booms

 

I shall visit Israel when the Lebanon and Gaza have ceased to be testing grounds for bodies blackened and deformed beyond recognition by new weapons

 

I shall visit Israel when Israel has ceased to invade her neighbours on the slightest of pretexts and cause devastation

 

I shall visit Israel when 11,870 Palestinian prisoners and 51 Palestinian MPs have been released from jail and pardoned for acts or words of resistance

 

Against a state that for 60 years has been taking their country by force of arms, terror and the law of the powerful

 

I shall visit Israel when the routine practice of torture has stopped

 

But will it still be Israel?

 

I shall visit Israel when Lieberman has left the country

 

I shall visit Israel when the illegal villages have been made legal

 

I shall visit Israel when the Bedouin of the Negev are free to live as they wish

 

I shall visit Israel when Arab towns and villages have been granted the same status and funding as Jewish ones

 

I shall visit Israel when the land has been shared by all Semites

 

I shall visit Israel when the rich white Jews no longer freely water the lawns of their villas in Tel-Aviv,

 

Those on the West Bank have to buy their drinking water and the people of Gaza have nothing safe to drink at all

 

But will it still be Israel?

 

I shall visit Israel when the people of Gaza reach a great white city North of Jaffa, raise the flag and live there

 

I shall visit Israel when Al-Quds has become the capital

 

I shall visit Israel when the Jewish state has become an unhappy memory

 

I shall visit Israel when Nazi war crimes against the Jews are no longer the excuse for every imaginable cruelty in a land to which they came as uninvited guests and remained as conquerors…

 

I shall visit Israel when the name of Israel no longer causes fear and hatred of the Jews

 

Because Israel has vanished from the page of time

 

When these conditions prevail

 

I shall be happy to visit Palestine when the olive trees are in bloom

Paul Grenville  July 2008

 

One Response

  1. Hi Nahida, the poem has now been translated into Arabic by a girl from Gaza City called Maha Dia. Here it is:
    https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=explorer&chrome=true&srcid=1tpA2RAmJpteKG8MkEnHQcNV0D4KpL2bDT4wjvb7v8e-fXEaMAjYQ4NDKzgwF&authkey=CPqxrtUJ&hl=en

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

James Perloff

formerly refugebooks.com

zaidpub

A Muslim's View

billziegler1947

ziegler.bill@gmail.com

| truthaholics

Exposing Truth Behind Media Spin

No Time to Think

The words, poems, stories and thoughts of award winning writer and journalist, Nic Outterside

Plato's Guns

M i d e a s t Newsstand

Palestine Momentum

Writers For Palestine

Poetry for Palestine

Palestine, Poetry, Truth-Seeking,

WikiPeeks Blog

Truth is just around the corner

مدونة عزت غيث

قوانين، مذكرات، مقالات المحامي عزت غيث مكتب المحامي عزت نصر غيث : عمان - جبل الحسين - دوار فراس - عمارة قدورة تلفون 0797900678 - 0788850180

themharaintifada

Just another WordPress.com site

Strings of Soulfulness

The strings of my life’s soulfulness in the beauty of eternity.

مدوّنة مريم

“Each generation must discover its mission, fulfill it or betray it, in relative opacity.”

YA BAKİ ENTEL BAKİ

"İlahi Ente Maksudi ve Rızake Matlubi"

The question of Palestine

Palestine is still the question

gabrielarad06

This WordPress.com site is an experiment

لماذا غزة؟ Why Gaza?

An American searching for answers in the Middle East

Fig Trees and Vineyards

A blog by Richard Edmondson

Rehmat's World

"There is no compulsion in religion," - Holy Qur'an

hussienclimateleaders

The Climate Crises

PALESTINE FROM MY EYES

Generating a fearless and humanising narrative on Palestine!

American Everyman

"The Future is not inherited, it is Achieved" JFK

Uprootedpalestinians's Blog

Palestinians are at the heart of the conflict in the M.E Palestinians uprooted by force of arms.. Yet faced immense difficulties have survived, kept alive their history and culture, passed keys of family homes in occupied Palestine from one generation to the next.

The Ugly Truth

Intelligent 'anti-Semitism' for thinking Gentiles

My Palestine

The Scribbling of an ordinary Palestinian from occupied Palestine

Eye On Palestine

By the Palestinian Photographer Ahmad Mesleh

The Passionate Attachment

America's entanglement with Israel

Occupied Palestine | فلسطين

Blogging 4 Human Rights & Liberation of Palestine! فلسطين

Mystery Worshiper's Blog

The Prince of Peace does not "take out" (assassinate) world leaders.

The Slog.

An antidote to ideology

Aletho News

ΑΛΗΘΩΣ

John's Consciousness

Exploring our "Inner Evolution"

Sami, The Bedouin.

Writing from and for Palestine

Maidhc Ó Cathail

Writing and Analysis

%d bloggers like this: